1601 East-West Road, Honolulu, HI 96848 info@pacificrisa.org 808.944.7111

Lessons from the Galapagos

Coastal, social and ecological vulnerability – lessons from the Galapagos Islands, Ecuador

During her postdoctoral fellowship with the Center for Galapagos Studies at the University of North Carolina, Pacific RISA Fellow Dr. Laura Brewington conducted field research in the Galapagos Islands of Ecuador, using a methodology that is relevant to Hawaii and other Pacific islands that are vulnerable to climate change and other factors. Mixed methods were used to assess social and ecological vulnerability of coastal environments, and form the baseline for future change detection.

The oil spill caused by the grounding of the tanker the Jessica in January 2001 led to calls for the creation of a management response network in Galapagos for preparation for coastal hazards. One decade later, the two tsunamis altered the configuration of shorelines areas that are home to burgeoning human populations and nesting grounds for endemic species. To anticipate the scale and impacts of climate change, natural hazards, and human use, novel and transferable vulnerability assessment approaches are required – especially in diverse and fragile island settings. Coastal areas are critical transition zones between land and the open ocean, providing essential ecosystem services like shoreline protection, nutrient cycling, fisheries resources, habitat and food, and regulation of nutrients, water, and organisms.

Img1_pto_villamil

The coastal village of Puerto Villamil, Isabela Island (population 2,500)

Our pilot project in 2013 created a database of linked spatial, social, and environmental indicators of vulnerability for the Galapagos coastline. First we assigned values from 1 (very low) to 5 (very high) to a set of eight vulnerability criteria for 13 focal areas in the archipelago. We chose four local factors (land use, land cover, remoteness, human use intensity) and four external factors (orientation, connectivity, topography, and geomorphology). Criteria were evaluated using a combination of qualitative and quantitative measures, including shoreline surveys, three-dimensional terrain scanning, land cover interpretation using aerial photography, and sediment sampling. To address gaps in the available data and to obtain historical information on these criteria we solicited information from key informants in marine science, conservation, and tourism in Galapagos.

Vulnerability criteria for each study area were entered into a GIS to develop virtual beach models that can be compared among sites for common characteristics. In the four sites where urban development is present we used a set of indicators from census and survey data to assign levels of social and economic vulnerability at the block level, and with satellite imagery classified these areas into meaningful categories that may be associated with vulnerability – such as land cover types, urban development indices, and the presence/absence of invasive species. Moving forward we expect to combine established characteristics of each type of coastal habitat and associated vulnerability with satellite imagery to create a comprehensive vulnerability profile of all beaches in the Galapagos, for use in marine and terrestrial spatial planning and mitigation of environmental hazards. Identifying focal areas for monitoring and management activities is an essential component of the Pacific RISA program, supporting informed decision-making about climate change and other future hazards.

Img2_worldview-2

Puerto Villamil from above, using Worldview-2 satellite imagery from 2010 and the census blocks overlaid to indicate regions that exhibit high social and ecological vulnerability characteristics in yellow.

Congressional Briefing

Congressional briefing by Pacific RISA on Capitol Hill

Drs. Melissa Finucane and Victoria Keener were a part of a congressional briefing on Capitol Hill, Washington DC yesterday where the topic of the day were the impacts of climate change in the Pacific and what the implications of these would be for policy and decision makers. The discussions were centered around the East-West Center led Pacific Islands Regional Climate Assessment (PIRCA), which is also to be included as part of the regional input to the federal government’s forthcoming National Climate Assessment.

Hawai’i Senator Brian Schatz said that, “In Hawai’i and throughout the Pacific, climate change is not an abstract concept – it is already having very real consequences. Decreased freshwater supplies, higher air and sea surface temperatures, rising sea levels, and beach erosion are all major concerns that could permanently affect our economy and environment. We cannot afford to keep waiting while some lawmakers drag their feet. Instead, we must invest in clean energy and decrease our dependence on foreign oil now. I thank the East-West Center and the Pacific Islands Regional Climate Assessment for joining me in working to broaden the conversation and seek solutions.”

Header image: Senator Brian Schatz speaking at the congressional briefing. Source: Office of Senator Brian Schatz.

Social Network Analysis

Pacific RISA’s Network Analysis at the 2013 American Psychological Association Convention

The American Psychological Association (APA) is the largest professional and scientific organization of psychologists in the United States made up of more than 134,000 members. The most recent APA Convention was held in Honolulu, Hawaii from July 31st to August 4th. Pacific RISA was represented by Dr. Kati Corlew, Research Fellow, who presented a poster on the continued network analysis research of climate change professionals in the region. For the results and maps related to this project, please click here.

APA SNA Poster Corlew_RN1Dr. Kati Corlew, Research Fellow, at the 2013 APA Convention.

As there are usually between 11,000 – 14,000 people who attend the APA Conventions, it provided an excellent opportunity to elicit feedback from a wide variety of attendees working with the psychological dimensions of this research. “There was a lot of interest in using network analysis to study communication and collaboration at all levels”, said Dr. Corlew. “Even more so in the way it was being applied to research and communication in the Pacific with regard to climate change professionals.”

Dr. Corlew believes that presenting at the APA Convention has strengthened the social network analysis research because of feedback from statisticians, for example, about how to apply this research to future analyses examining why people become connected to a network. Dr. Corlew was further able to discuss with national and international colleagues how Psychology can best contribute to climate change research and communicate Pacific efforts to an audience from the mainland United States and Europe.

The APA Conventions are one of the premiere conventions in the field of Psychology and Dr. Corlew was honored to be able to share part of the research that Pacific RISA is undertaking in the human dimensions, or social sciences, of climate change.

Extreme Events in the RMI

Coastal inundation in the Marshall Islands forebodes the future of extreme events

On Tuesday, waves inundated the southern part of Majuro, the capital of the Republic of the Marshall Islands (RMI), flooding homes and causing extensive damage to property. The waves reached two and a half meters high, according to Majuro Weather Service meteorologist Reggie White, who serves on Pacific RISA’s Advisory Committee. The flooding caused the Majuro airport to close for the day, after the runway seawall crumbled under the weight of the waves, and a United Airlines flight bound for Majuro was redirected. High swells could persist for several days, so residents are doing what they can to prepare for further inundation possible through Thursday.

Inundation from the high tide event and storm surge flooded neighborhoods of southern Majuro, causing extensive damage to people’s homes and crops. Photo by Anole Valdez, 2013. All rights reserved.
A high tide event and storm surge flooded neighborhoods of southern Majuro, causing extensive damage to people’s homes and crops. Photo by Anole Valdez, 2013. All rights reserved.

Many parts of Majuro atoll are less than one meter above sea level and are therefore vulnerable to flooding during very high tides. This week’s events can be attributed to local weather (a storm produced high ocean swells), coinciding with an unusually high tide (a result of the recent supermoon); yet, such events are very likely to increase in frequency and severity as sea-level continues to rise.  Whether or not future storm patterns change over the next century, the impact that rising average water levels will have on such extreme events is well recognized.  A study focusing on Australian sea-level stations estimated that an increase of 10 cm (about 4 inches) in average water level corresponds to a threefold increase in the frequency of extreme events on average (Hunter, 2012).  Thus, an increase of 20 cm (about 8 inches) will mean that what is currently a 100-year inundation event will become a 10-year event on average. The picture is clear—cities and villages on low-lying islands such as the Marshalls will be at heightened risk for severe flooding in the future.

Majuro residents will tell you that the increasing frequency of these situations and the effects of sea-level rise are already visible. In places where the coastline is eroding, trees and plants are removed as a result, and the waves have an easier time coming up. Coastal erosion is a natural long-term, dynamic process; however, sea-level rise is increasing the rate of erosion in many places, and loss of land at the shoreline is evident. As infrastructure becomes threatened, more and more structures to protect land from the ocean (seawalls, rubble mounds, etc.) are being built on Majuro, and seawalls now cover nearly the entire coastline of Majuro city and the eastern part of the atoll. While seawalls can protect against more minor high tide events, they may be overtopped by waves in more extreme events, as they were on Tuesday.  Seawalls, in fact, can accelerate erosion of nearby beaches by disturbing natural coastal processes that transport beach sediment along the shoreline and by increasing the force of waves due to wave reflection off the seawall.  Thus, there are obvious limits to this kind of protective structure as a long-term solution.

As low-lying islands face a wide range of impacts due to increased water levels and the possibility of more frequent extreme inundation events, places like RMI will require assistance from other governments and the international community in order to appropriately address the near-term and long-term threats.  The U.S. Congress is currently debating an immigration reform bill, and Senator Brian Schatz of the State of Hawai‘i has proposed an amendment that would give a legal status to people displaced by climate change.  The amendment would allow the U.S. government to designate individuals or groups of individuals displaced permanently by climate change as stateless persons, identifying climate change, like war, as a potential major cause of homelessness in the world.  This move both signifies the severity of the problem that island countries are facing, and recognizes that now is the time for Pacific Islands together with other governments to put in place measures to prepare for a possibly not-so-distant future when such legal structures, as well as broader adaptation policies, will be needed.

Waves crashing over a seawall in Majuro during the June 25, 2013 flooding. Photo by Murray Ford, 2013. All rights reserved.
Waves crashing over a seawall in Majuro during the June 25, 2013 flooding. Photo by Murray Ford, 2013. All rights reserved.

References

Huang, T. and Rapp, H. (2010). Coastal Erosion on Majuro Atoll : Marshall Islands with Special Regard to Sea-Level Rise (Master thesis). Available from Division of Water Resources Engineering, Department of Building and Environmental Technology, Lund University, http://www.lunduniversity.lu.se/o.o.i.s?id=24965&postid=1670491

Hunter, J. (2012). A simple technique for estimating an allowance for uncertain sea-level rise. Climate Change, 113(2), 239-252. doi:10.1007/s10584-011-0332-1

Johnson, G. (2013, June 26). Marshalls capital inundated by high tide. Marianas Variety, Regional News, Palau/Pacific News. Retrieved from http://www.mvariety.com/index.php/regional-news/palaupacific-news/56955-marshalls-capital-inundated-by-high-tide

Keener, V.W., Marra, J.J., Finucane, M.L., Spooner, D., & Smith, M.H. (Eds.). (2012).  Climate Change and Pacific Islands:  Indicators and Impacts.  Report for the 2012 Pacific Islands Regional Climate Assessment.  (Chapter  3: Sea Level and Coastal Inundation on Pacific Islands.) Washington, DC: Island Press. Available from www.PacificRISA.org/projects/PIRCA.

Leber, R. (2013, June 20). Amendment Would Give Legal Status To People Displaced By Climate Change. Message posted to http://thinkprogress.org/immigration/2013/06/20/2187831/climate-refugee-immigration-bill/?mobile=nc

Pope, T. (2013, June 25). Marshall Islands bracing for more destructive seas. Australia Network News. Retrieved from http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-06-25/an-marshall-islands-braced-for-more-flooding/4779164

Information Sharing in the Pacific

Can Network Analysis Strengthen Information Sharing in the Pacific?

Pacific RISA recently launched a multi-year social network analysis project to examine how climate information spreads across different sectors and countries in the Pacific Islands region. Using the December 2012 release of the Pacific Islands Regional Climate Assessment (PIRCA) report as a spring board, researchers are collecting data to analyze the networks of climate change scientists and professionals.

To learn more about social network analysis, Pacific RISA Communications Coordinator Zena Grecni spoke with Dr. Kati Corlew, who is a community and cultural psychologist and serves as the project’s Research Fellow. She provided great insights about their research methods and the study’s importance to Pacific RISA’s mission.

Zena:  Thank you for talking with me today, Kati.

Kati:  Of course! Thank you, Zena.

Zena:  To start off, what is social network analysis, and why did you select this method to look at how information is shared in the Pacific region?

Kati:  Social network analysis is a way to look at connections and relationships in communities of people. With network analysis, we can explore statistical theories, but we can also create a map of these relationships to graphically reveal reasons, motivations, and implications behind them. We chose network analysis for this project because in the Pacific, climate change projects cross sectors, regions, and fields of study. We have a strong sense of collaboration, but at the same time, we all want to know how to make these collaborations stronger. With network analysis, we can see where the strengths are in our network of climate change professionals, and also identify opportunities for growth.

Zena:  Will the analysis be limited to connections among people living in the US-Affiliated Pacific Islands, or does it look at regional and international flows of information as well?

Kati:  We are focused on Hawaiʻi and the USAPI, but much of the work done in this region is necessarily broader in scope. There are a number of climate change professionals who work in our region but who are based elsewhere. So, we expanded the network to capture these realities. We have participants from other parts of the Pacific, from the US mainland, and from all over the world.

Zena:  How many people did you expect to reach?  And, how many actually responded?

Kati:  Well, we were hoping for hundreds, and that’s what we got. We have 340 participants currently, and I expect a few more will be trickling in over the next few weeks.

Zena:  It sounds like you’ve been successful in collecting a lot of data. What do you hope to learn from the analysis?

Kati:  We’re doing two types of analysis. First, we will look for strengths and gaps in our communications network. This information will help anyone in our field get an idea of where, and with whom, they might want to work in the future. I’m hoping this information will also be useful when agencies are requesting funds for future projects. Like, “Here is proof that we are really connected in this area.” Or, “Hey, we really want to improve our connections to this other area.”

Kati:  The second type of analysis has to do with the theoretical drivers of network connection and our understanding of risk, as climate change professionals. With confidential, aggregated data, we will explore how network connection is related to climate change risk perception and to our psychological sense of community with other professionals. From this we hope to learn more about how and why people become actively involved in a community of climate change professionals.

Zena:  Have you had any surprises so far, in looking at the survey data?

Kati:  Wow, for me? I was surprised to realize how many professionals we knew (or knew of) who worked in climate change-related fields in Hawaiʻi versus other US -Affiliated Pacific Islands. I was able to compile a list of almost 500 people from Hawaiʻi, but for example in Palau I could only find contact information for 35 people. That’s a big difference, and already we can see that we need to further develop connections and capacity for future collaborations in Palau.

Zena:  How will the data and results be displayed?

Kati:  For the network connections, I am building a giant digital map. It will be broken down by physical region as well as by profession, to make it easier to search for strengths and collaboration opportunities. This will be freely available through our website. We’ll also write up what we learn in fact sheets, short reports, and journal articles.

Zena:  What is the ultimate significance of this project to Pacific Island decision makers and to those who provide information about climate to communities?

Kati:  The biggest takeaway is that we are connected throughout our region. We all know this—we are a series of islands connected by the ocean. But there is always room to build these connections. By mapping out how we communicate, we can find how best to strengthen our community.

There you have it, everyone, straight from social network analysis researcher Dr. Kati Corlew.  If you have additional questions about Pacific RISA’s social network analysis project, you may contact Kati at corlewk@EastWestCenter.org, or email us at info@PacificRISA.org. You can also find more information on the social network analysis project page.

 

Drought in the RMI

Severe Drought Affects the Northern Atolls of the Republic of the Marshall Islands

A persistent drought in the Republic of the Marshall Islands (RMI) has reached a severe level, affecting 8,000 to 10,000 people of the northern atolls. There has been little rainfall in the northern Marshall Islands this year, and well water is turning brackish, making it unsafe to drink or use for crop irrigation. With no alternative source of fresh water, the Marshallese Government has declared the drought a national disaster. In addition to the drinking water shortage, island communities are facing the threat of communicable disease as well as food shortage, as many subsistence food gardens have suffered from the drought.

Clint Simpson of the National Weather Service Office in Guam told Radio New Zealand that a high pressure system is lingering over the Central Pacific, causing the dry weather conditions. Typically, dry spells are offset by Trade Wind showers, but not this time. Forecasters warn that the drought is likely to get much worse in the weeks to come, as no rain is forecast for the near future. In fact, the drought may last through July, or possibly longer.

The Marshall Islands’ Foreign Minister, Phillip Muller, reports that the government conducted an assessment of the impacts on communities and says that the situation is “quite dire.” The United States government is making their own assessment, and if the need is found to exceed one million dollars, the US President will allow for additional aid to the country.  The US has already delivered solar-powered reverse osmosis equipment that can supply a small amount of water (about 300 gallons daily), but it will not be enough for island populations. The Australian government has also provided US$100,000 in emergency desalinization units. The United Nations recently sent an emergency grant and an assessment team to the RMI. Jens Laerke, a spokesperson for the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs said, “The lack of clean drinking water is of acute humanitarian concern, and children are particularly vulnerable.”

While the water shortage is worsening for families in the northern islands, atolls south of the capital of Majuro have received enough rain to be spared dangerous water shortages. The large municipal reservoir at the Majuro Airport held 20 million gallons as of mid-April, which is a little over half of capacity.

The latest issue of the Pacific ENSO Applications Climate (PEAC) Center’s quarterly newsletter, released in early May, reports that rainfall should slowly build back to normal across the RMI, starting with Majuro in May, Kwajalein by June, and into the drought-stricken northern islands by July. Download the full newsletter, with climate conditions and outlooks for each Pacific Island group, here.

The Republic of the Marshall Islands. Map created by: Miguel Castrence and Luisa Young . Data sources: Natural Earth, VLIZ Maritime Boundaries Geodatabase v6, ESRI World Imagery, EarthSat NaturalVue, Pacific Disaster Center.
The Republic of the Marshall Islands. Map created by: Miguel Castrence and Luisa Young . Data sources: Natural Earth, VLIZ Maritime Boundaries Geodatabase v6, ESRI World Imagery, EarthSat NaturalVue, Pacific Disaster Center.

References

Australia To Assist RMI Amidst Severe Drought Conditions.  Radio Australia. 6 May 2013. Available from http://pidp.eastwestcenter.org/pireport/2013/May/05-07-10.htm.

The Marshalls Islands has declared a state of disaster in the island nation’s North due to the prolonged drought. Radio Australia. 10 May 2013. Available from http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacific/radio/program/pacific-beat/marshall-islands-declares-national-drought-disaster/1129120.

Marshall Islands drought to get much worse – forecaster.  Radio New Zealand, International.  7 May 2013. Available from http://www.rnzi.com/pages/news.php?op=read&id=75859.

UN disaster assessment team arrives in drought-affected Marshall Islands. UN News Centre. 10 May 2013. Available from http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=44871&Cr=drought&Cr1=#.UY2cM0rihYU.

The Pacific ENSO Applications Climate Center. Pacific ENSO Update,  2nd Quarter, 2013 Vol. 19, No. 2.,  issued May 2, 2013. Available from http://www.prh.noaa.gov/peac/peu/2013_2nd/PEU_v19_n2.pdf.

Cover photo:  Namorik Atoll, in the Republic of the Marshall Islands. Courtesy of Darren Nakata.

Less Rainfall for Hawai‘i

UH Mānoa climate research:  less rainfall expected for Hawai‘i

The latest Hawai‘i rainfall study, published March 13 in an early online issue of Journal of Geophysical Research, supports the findings of earlier research at the University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa, but it goes beyond analyzing historical trends and looks at a critical issue:  whether the drying trend that Hawai‘i has been experiencing since 1978 will continue.  The research team, led by Oliver Elison Timm at the International Pacific Research Center (IPRC), finds that the drying trend is indeed likely to continue through the end of the century.

Modeling Hawai‘i’s climate presents many challenges because of Hawai‘i’s complex topography and the coarse resolution of global climate models.  To meet the challenge, the team used statistical downscaling—a method for relating local observations (usually at the station-level) to features of large-scale global models for the same time period. These statistical relationships are then applied to global climate models for the future to see how local climate may be affected.

“The patterns we saw did not surprise us,” recalled Dr. Elison Timm, referring to the historical data. “For example, we found that the typical winter Kona storms with moist air-flow from the South often produce torrential rains in the islands.”

Photo courtesy of the International Pacific Research Center
Photo courtesy of the International Pacific Research Center

They found that the large circulation patterns over the mid-latitude and tropical North Pacific have already shifted since 1978 so that fewer weather disturbances reach the Islands during the rainy season from November through April.  Combining information from their statistical model and cutting-edge climate models driven with the projected increase in greenhouse gases, the scientists conclude that we can expect the recent trend towards drier winter seasons with fewer heavy-rain days to continue through the end of this century.

“It is extremely difficult to take all the uncertainties into account and our overall result may not apply to all sites in Hawai‘i,” cautioned Senior Researcher Henry Diaz from the University of Colorado. “We are just beginning to understand the details of how climate change will affect the Hawaiian Islands.”

The project was supported by grants from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service through the Pacific Island Climate Change Cooperative (PICCC) and the Pacific Islands Climate Science Center. Additional funding was provided jointly by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Honolulu District, and the Commission on Water Resource Management, Hawai‘i Department of Land and Natural Resources.

Citation:  Oliver Elison Timm, Mami Takahashi, Thomas W. Giambelluca, and Henry F. Diaz, 2013: On the Relation between Large-Scale Circulation Pattern and Heavy Rain Events over the Hawaiian Islands: Recent Trends and Future Changes. Journal of Geophysical Research, (early online-release in March 2013, http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/jgrd.50314/abstract)

Cover Photo:  A waterfall in Ka‘au Crater, O‘ahu, Hawai‘i. (Source: Victoria Keener)

Pacific Islands Drought Monitoring

The capacities and challenges for drought monitoring in the Pacific Islands

Pacific RISA Research Fellow Dr. Kati Corlew recently returned from the 2013 US Drought Monitor Forum, held this year April 16-18 in West Palm Beach, Florida.  Dr. Corlew gave a presentation that introduced to the drought monitoring community the unique circumstances encountered in the efforts to monitor and measure drought levels in the Hawaiian Islands and the US-Affiliated Pacific Islands (USAPI).  The US Drought Monitor is a national program that tracks indicators and impacts of drought in localities across the US. The US Drought Monitor website contains a drought map that has been refined over time to reflect the needs of decision makers and those who use the information. Drought Monitor authors synthesize many drought indicators into this single map that identifies areas of the country that are abnormally dry (D0), in moderate drought (D1), in severe drought (D2), extreme drought (D3) and exceptional drought (D4).  While the Drought Monitor already covers the 48 contiguous states, Hawai‘i , Alaska, and Puerto Rico, several federal partners are now working to bring a US Drought Monitoring-style system to the USAPI region.  The tool is being designed to report the specific conditions of the Pacific Islands on a weekly basis.  Therefore, those working on this expansion of the tool, as well as partners from the other regions of the US, were interested to hear from Dr. Corlew about the capacities and challenges of monitoring the Pacific Islands.

What is the current status of the Pacific Islands Drought Monitor?

At last week’s forum, Dr. Corlew represented not only Pacific RISA, but also two federal offices working hard to build drought monitoring and reporting capacity in the Pacific Islands:  The Pacific ENSO Applications Climate (PEAC) Center, based in Honolulu, and the National Climatic Data Center (NCDC). The Pacific Islands drought monitoring tool may be connected to the US Drought Monitor in the coming few months, or may be integrated into one of two other tools—the North American Drought Monitor or the Global Drought Monitor. Important next steps include moving the monthly scientific consensus discussions about Pacific Islands drought levels and impacts to weekly, which will put them in line with the US Drought Monitor’s weekly reports. To do this, partners must automate the precipitation data system to report daily precipitation levels. PEAC and NCDC expect to put these improvements into action over the next few months.

View the Presentation

Dr. Kati Corlew’s presentation about drought monitoring in the Pacific Islands is available to download and view here (3.20 MB):

Drought Monitor Forum Presentation_Corlew

About the US Drought Monitor

The U.S. Drought Monitor map is jointly produced by the National Drought Mitigation Center at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, the U.S. Department of Agriculture, and about 350 drought observers across the country. It is released each Thursday based on data through the previous Tuesday.